2010 Rochester Red Wings Preview

7 Apr

also available at www.SethSpeaks.net

The 2010 Twins minor league roster previews are brought to you by the Minnesota Twins 2010 Prospect Handbook. Get your copy here!

Second, I will be on KFAN at 10:30 central time with Paul Allen. If you can get it on the radio, great. If not, head over to KFAN.com and listen live.

And, by the way, if you’re able to, be sure to join me and the rest of TwinsCentric at Majors Sports Café in Blaine on Saturday from 11:30 a.m. until the end of the Twins/White Sox game. Drink and appetizer specials. Lots of prizes to give away. Lots of talk with Twins fans. It’d be fun to meet you!

On Thursday night, Anthony Swarzak will take the mound for the Rochester Red Wings against Boof Bonser and Pawtucket. Tom Nieto will be the Red Wings manager in 2010 after leading the New Britain Rockcats a year ago. Floyd Rayford will be the hitting coach while Bobby Cuellar is the pitching coach. Let’s take a look at players on the Red Wings roster to start the 2010 season (note – prospect ranking for my choices for Top 30 Twins prospects as updated in the Minnesota Twins 2010 Prospect Handbook):

The Starting Pitchers

Anthony Swarzak, Jeff Manship (16), Glen Perkins, Mike Maroth, Yoslan Herrera.

As far as upside, I think most would agree that Glen Perkins could be the most talented pitcher in this group. Does that mean he’s the best pitcher? Probably not. Manship and Swarzak both profile as back of the rotation starters. Both showed in 2009, in short stints with the Twins, that they are capable big league pitchers, but they also both showed that they have more to learn. Having talked with Manship several times, I know that he’ll take a lot from what he learned at the big league level and incorporate it into his game. I like to assume the same for Swarzak. Mike Maroth is a veteran. He was the last 20 game loser in the big leagues. I had so much respect for him during his Tigers days for being strong enough mentally to keep pitching, and he wasn’t as bad as that win-loss record indicated. Of course, a couple of years later, he was that bad and out of baseball. This spring, he was given a chance by the Twins and had a solid camp, so he can be a veteran in the AAA rotation. Herrera signed a four year contract with the Pittsburgh Pirates after defecting from Cuba. Those four years are up. He became a free agent and signed with the Twins. At 28, he’s not a prospect, but he has been solid enough in the minor leagues that this is a worthy risk to take. I also believe that Matt Fox and Ryan Mullins will each get an opportunity to start at some point during the season.

The Bullpen Arms

Anthony Slama (23), Rob Delaney, Jose Lugo, Kyle Waldrop, Tim Lahey, Matt Fox, Ryan Mullins, Ron Mahay.

The back-end of the Twins bullpen is incredibly talented and should be a strength of this roster. Anthony Slama has done nothing but dominate since signing in early 2007. Rob Delaney has been just about as good, although he struggled more in his time in AAA than did Slama. Jose Lugo is pretty similar to Jose Mijares. Occasional lapses and loss of control, but has tremendous stuff, especially against lefties. Kyle Waldrop was a pleasant surprise in camp this spring. The non-roster invitee was one of the Twins first-round picks in 2004 out of his Tennessee high school. He missed all of 2008 with surgery in his shoulder. He stayed healthy in 2009 and should be strong in 2010. Fellow 2004 first round pick Matt Fox and 2005 3rd round pick will be the righty and lefty (respectively) to pitch out of the bullpen, and as I said earlier, both could get opportunities to start. Tim Lahey was drafted as a catcher, and soon the Twins made him a reliever. He quickly worked through the system and last year he really struggled. But he lost nearly 30 pounds in the offseason and looked strong in camp, so it will be a very big year for the right-hander. And remember, in all likelihood, Alex Burnett will be optioned to Rochester, a place he has not yet played. But he could be the best relief pitching prospect in the Twins system too. Ron Mahay will start the season in Rochester, but he is expected to be up with the Twins relatively soon. Big league veteran, Brad Hennessey, who had a couple of very good years with the San Francisco Giants, missed last year and will spend the first couple of months this year. But this was a nice

The Catchers

Wilson Ramos (2), Allan de San Miguel.

When it came to on-field, baseball decisions, Wilson Ramos was probably the story of spring training. Ramos did not lose the battle to Drew Butera, but Butera was – rightfully – given the Twins backup catcher duties until the return of Jose Morales. Ramos is an incredible prospect. I ranked him the team’s #2 prospect this winter. He has displayed an ability to hit for both average and power, and play a very solid catcher defensively. The incredible thing is that he isn’t even the top prospect in the International League this year. Both Jesus Montero of the Yankees and Carlos Santana of the Indians will also be playing in the league.

De San Miguel has been in the Twins farm system for a long time and yet he is still just 23 years old. He knows and understands that his future with the Twins is as a backup catcher, and he has embraced the role. Offensively, he hasn’t hit for average or power, but he has really improved his ability to get on base. But again, that’s all secondary to what he provides for the pitching staff. Jose Morales would likely rehab in Rochester at some point, and when he returns to the Twins, Drew Butera would likely come back to Rochester to back up Ramos.

The Infielders

Brock Peterson, Luke Hughes (27), Trevor Plouffe (21), Danny Valencia (7), Erik Lis, Matt Tolbert, (Matt Macri)

Peterson became a free agent this past offseason, but the Twins were happily able to bring him back. He was the Red Wings top hitter in the second half of 2009. Plus, it’s fun to cheer for a former 49th round draft pick! Erik Lis likely will not play much first base and will get plenty of at bats as the team’s designated hitter. This is a big year for Trevor Plouffe. He’s still just 23, but now in his third year at Rochester. With the acquisition of JJ Hardy, Plouffe may need to play other positions as well. Danny Valencia is immensely talented, and there are questions at 3B with the Twins. There could be a scenario in which he is up with the Twins by June, but most of that depends as much on the performances of Nick Punto and Brendan Harris, along with his own performance. Matt Tolbert, simply, is not very good, but he can play all around the infield and on opening night, he will actually be the Red Wings leadoff hitter and center fielder. Ron Gardenhire loves him, so he likely remains in the plans. Matt Macri begins the season on the Disabled List.

The Outfielders

Brian Dinkelman, Jason Repko, Jacque Jones, Dustin Martin, (Brandon Roberts)

Jacque Jones was one of the great Twins stories of spring training. Brought back for camp, almost as a courtesy for all he did at the beginning of last decade for the team, Jones was not going to make the big league roster. But he almost did, and now he will head to Rochester. If a need arises in the outfield for the Twins, Jones might be the first promoted. On Monday, the Twins signed Jason Repko, a centerfielder who had spent time with the Los Angeles Dodgers four of the past five seasons. Not a great hitter, he is right-handed and probably the best option to play center field. Dustin Martin had a very good 2008, a strong performance in the Arizona Fall League, and a nice showing in spring training 2009. And then the season started, and Martin didn’t even get an invite to big league training camp this year. Brian Dinkelman was a second baseman throughout his career, until Steve Singleton was promoted to New Britain last year. Then Dinkelman started playing in the outfield, and he performed fairly well. A good contact hitter who finds ways to get on base, I think he will be hitting near the top of the Red Wings order throughout the year. Finally, Brandon Roberts spent most of the past two years in New Britain, on their Disabled List, and that’s where he will begin the 2010 season with the Red Wings.


Overall, I think this is a very solid roster. For AAA, it is a good mix of veteran players, with decent AAAA types of players and a good number of prospects who will likely contribute to some degree, some significantly, in the next couple of seasons. On Opening Night, Danny Valencia will be batting 8th with Brian Dinkelman betting 9th. I’m not saying agree with that, but if that is the case, this should be a very strong lineup. As I mentioned before, the back end of the bullpen should be very strong, so the starters can hopefully provide at least six good innings each night. The fans in Rochester should get to see some quality baseball this season. Hopefully they can not only develop players for the Twins to use as necessary, but also compete for a playoff spot in the International League.  

If you have any questions or comments on this preview of the roster, please feel free to ask… Leave your questions or comments.


10 Responses to “2010 Rochester Red Wings Preview”

  1. mike wants wins April 8, 2010 at 9:32 am #

    That’s a very nice pitching staff. It may not have a high end “ace type”, but it has plenty of good prospects as starers, and guys that could (or maybe should) be in the pen at the MLB level.

    The OF doesn’t do much for me. I don’t know that I see a single number 4 guy there, let alone a starting MLB OFer.

    The IFers contains guys that aren’t that good, but that Gardy likes. Kind of frustrating for me. I still have this belief in Plouffe that is getting harder and harder to justify. However, I think he still has a chance to be good. Hughes will be a DH/2B/OF type for some MLB team some day, a guy that plays for a handful of years, and maybe contributes to some winning, but is unlikely to be a star of any kind.

    Catcher – well, I think I’ve made it clear that Ramos should be in the majors (or traded for a real 3B), so I like that position a lot for Rochester.

    I do agree that there should be guys that may not be MLB players, but that are AAA/AAAA types on a AAA roster. I’m hopeful the Twins have given the fans there a better roster to watch this year. I think they should be happy with that team (and should watch Ramos while they have a chance).

  2. thrylos98 April 8, 2010 at 10:48 am #


    Mahay is headed to Ft. Myears for a “tune-up”. I suspect that he might or might not end up with the Twins this season, but Condrey got dibs on Alex Burnett’s spot. Burnett will be great in Rochester

  3. Joel Thingvall April 8, 2010 at 11:46 am #

    Looks good in Rochester. A few names that can move out (Maroth, Macri, Jones, Repko) if the Twins wish to promote mid-season.

    Plouffe will get a shot with the Twins. Probably as a backup in 2011. The Twins are rich in that area…Tolbert will be abck then, too, with either Harris and Casilla starting at second, I would assume.

    The Twins don’t really need a 4th outfielder until 2012 with Cuddy, Span, Young and Kubel all under contract, so the guys at Rochester are just emergency names if someone does go down in major league land.

    It will be time for some names like Waldorf and Fox and Lugo to shine. Mullins will be interesting. I do wodner if Swarzak or Manship will be in the rotation in 2011.

    • thrylos98 April 8, 2010 at 11:55 am #

      Punto will be out in 2011 as well, so there is room for Plouffe but he would have to beat both Tolbert and Casilla (or they would have to be gone)

      • Micky April 8, 2010 at 1:35 pm #

        Punto will be back next year no way Gardy doesn’t have his boy back!

  4. Joel Thingvall April 8, 2010 at 11:47 am #

    Oh, check out http://www.twinscards.com and click on the home page rosters. I’m trying to keep the listings up to date and tracking the player movement during the season (which will be illustrated with cards as they come into my possession).

  5. mike wants wins April 8, 2010 at 2:14 pm #

    I also think Punto comes back in 2011. Casilla will prove what he isn’t this year, and they need a guy like Punto. They just need to pay him less.

    • ggg April 8, 2010 at 3:20 pm #

      mike wants wins where have you been? did you stop commenting on the strib blogs?

  6. mike wants wins April 8, 2010 at 4:36 pm #

    nope, I’m l6l6l6l, or something like that. but, I’ve been travelling for work lately, and not on much. Also, I’m not commenting on Young or Punto or most players right now….but I’m very excited about the new stadium. I MIGHT get to the Saturday get together…..but it will be tight timing for me.


  1. Minor League Spotlight: Rochester Red Wings | Mickerdoo - February 14, 2012

    […] a blog that follows the Minnesota Twins as well as their affiliates. Before the season started, he previewed the Rochester Red Wings. Twitter has proven to be a tremendous resource for following the minor leagues for news and […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: